Showing posts with label magazines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label magazines. Show all posts

Brains or Beauty?

I never wanted to be a model when I was younger. There were the small facts that I'm not that tall, I don't wear heels, and I've never liked having my picture taken, but I would have much rather won a Nobel Prize that graced the pages of a magazine.

To be overly simplistic, my motto was "Brains, not beauty."

Which is, like, all well and good, but I still secretly harbored a fantasy of getting some glamorous photo shoot and letting someone wax my eyebrows and being in a magazine. They have sexy firemen photo spreads- why not sexy women scientists?

Truth be told, I'll probably never be in a photo spread, and that's fine. But I learned this morning that I made it into Glamour magazine's online health blog!

You can see the article Whoa: Even Ancient Roman Women Worried About Being Thin Enough.

This same post is also on the blog HealthyGirl.org (same author!) Body Image News: Even Ancient Women Were Obsessed with Their Weight

I guess maybe I should try modeling this t-shirt?

Body Like Beckham

Good news: people are waking up to the fact that eating disorders actually happen to males.

Bad news: news coverage is the same old drivel.

"Now men fall prey to anorexia as they seek a body like Beckham"

These stories seem to go in one of two directions.

1) How horrible! Now even men are worried about their appearance! The fashion industry has gone too far.

(As if an industry that makes women paranoid is bad, but tolerable. Men? What is this world coming to?)

2) Tsk, tsk. Those silly boys. Falling prey to the same illusions that women have.

(Congratulations! You, too, were stupid enough to buy a plane ticket to the Land of Obsession!)

Have rates of eating disorders in males been rising? We don't know. Have diagnoses increased because awareness has increased? Almost certainly. But that doesn't mean an actual increase in the number of cases. People can (and do) suffer in silence.

Are increasing emphases on "eating healthy" and looking "ripped" influencing things? Almost certainly. But it's not a cause. A trigger, maybe. But a cause? No.

The cultural experience of an eating disorder in a male is going to be different than in a female. How he understands his illness, how others understand his illness- these things are bound to be different.

But the biological core? Pretty much the same.

Did anyone else think that picture (I'm assuming it was of Beckham himself, but I wouldn't know) was vaguely lewd? Almost pornographic? There are plenty of other pictures of this guy. If your article is about how these images are harming people, why are you using an image that is harming people?

posted under | 3 Comments

Lose weight fast!

You don't want to gain weight during the holidays, right? Not you! You will escape the gluttony that is the 5 weeks between Thanksgiving and New Years'.

Wait! You can do more! Not only can you keep from gainingweight, you can actually lose! That's right. You know that holiday party you've been dreading next weekend? The one you bought that sexy little black dress for that now doesn't fit because you had that extra slice of turkey on Thanksgiving and gained 20 pounds?

That dress.

You can wear it again. With these seven easy ways to lose ten pounds in ten minutes, you can impress your friends, rekindle your husband's waning desire, and make the slutty office secretary jealous.

  1. Amputate a limb! No longer is it no pain, no gain. It's also no pain, no loss! Call your doctor today and soon you will be able to lose up to 30 pounds with a few simple cuts.
  2. Before you step on the scale in the morning, pick up two 5-pound hand weights. With weights in hand, step on the scale. Note the number. Then, set the weights down and step back on the scale. The number should be ten pounds lower. Good for you!
  3. No hand weights? No problem! Buy a cheap, old-model bathroom scale. For this method to work, it can't be digital. Turn the dial on the scale so that it's set at 10 pounds below zero. Now step on the scale as usual. Ta-da! You weigh less!
  4. Buy a more expensive version of your little black dress. All women know that more expensive clothing means smaller sizes. You might not lose weight, but you'll be able to wear that size 4 you've always wanted.
  5. When you check your height, wear stilts. A guaranteed way to lower your BMI, without any fad diets or exercise.
  6. Encourage your friends to gain weight. You'll look thinner next to them.
  7. Use leeches. Blood has weight. If you let the leeches remove enough blood, your weight will go down. They've been used as a homeopathic remedy for ages, so it's guaranteed to be safe and improve your health.

See? Anyone can lose weight and improve their body image- in no time flat!!!

****************************************

I'm realizing that this is about as scientific and helpful as a lot of the other articles out there. I hope you, uh, enjoy it.

I found this articles funny until I realized that these people were being serious. Dead serious. Most of the people I know (who don't diet) don't really gain weight during the holidays. Why? It's just food. Seriously.


It's.

Just.

Food.

I'm not there yet. And over-indulging isn't one of my strong points. Even just typing the word "indulge" sends chills down my spine.

But there's also a huge difference between "enjoyment" and "gluttony". If a woman enjoys what she eats, she is somehow being a glutton. There aren't any "Hungry Woman" microwave dinners. There are Healthy Choice, Weight Watchers "Right Ones", and Lean Cuisine. Part of the reason I feel odd eating in front of other women (my male classmate notwithstanding because he has a hollow leg somewhere) is that I eat so much more than they do. I get that I have a pretty fast metabolism, that I'm pretty active. Yet I have a hard time, even after all of this, to eat more than someone else.

Women who eat a lot are pigs.

This is what our culture tells us. These weight loss articles really aren't geared towards men. They're not. Men don't have "vanity sizing." Not that they don't have their own food, weight, and body image issues.

And a shout out to Rachel at The F Word for inspiring this post.

Body as Aesthetics

So I'm in the supermarket checkout line, trying to ignore all of the stupid and toxic tabloids and celebrity magazines. The had an evaluation of "Top Beach Bods" and arrows pointing to "belly bulges" and cellulite.

Holy shit! You mean the people in Hollywood are...people? No way! I never would have guessed.

This brings up several points, namely: WHO CARES??? I don't get it.

This, combined with many of the headlines and features on women's and men's magazines, makes me realize: the body isn't about form and function. It's not even about function. It's all about form.

On those muscle magazines, do they ever say "Do these exercises so you can help save a person's life?" Or kick a potential mugger in the balls so hard they come flying out his nose?*

No. It's so potential partners will think you're hot, or you'll have six pack abs, or your biceps will be more defined, or many times, just because. Because you'll look better. Because you'll be healthier. Which is really the first one.

Weight loss is rarely promoted for health, not really. The doctor says to lose weight to lower your cholesterol, blood pressure, you name it. Many of them are no doubt well-meaning. But when you lose weight, your friend doesn't say, "You've lost weight! How much did your LDL levels go down?" No. They say, "You look great." Even when you're in the death throes of anorexia. My heart was failing and people were asking me for weight loss tips.

I'm sorry, but that's messed up. It's like asking a cancer patient how they get their cells to divide so freaking well.

Take one of my caveman analogies. I love them. They're so illuminating.

So we have our typical group of cavemen (oh, around 4 or 5) out hunting antelope. When they go to throw their spears, they're not precisely admiring their biceps. They're thinking "Mmmm...dinner." They might also be thinking "My wife is going to kick my balls out my nose if I don't bring dinner home" or that their buddy off Stage Left is going to do the same if they miss again. Whatever it is, they're not just staring at their biceps.

And can you imagine the women around the campfire, skinning the antelope. I doubt there's anyone in leopard-skin print legwarmers going, "Pull that skin back, ladies. Feel the burn. Feel the burn! Let's step it up! And march!" They're skinning the freaking antelope.

Yes, there's a lot to be said about form, function and the mating game. It's not purely one or the other. There should be a bit of both- you can't have function without form.

But think about it- that belly bulge on one of the celebrities? She had just given birth not all that long ago. A belly bulge. That woman nurtured another human life with her own body for nine months. And now she's supposed to get rid of all traces it ever happened? I hate to break it to you, but that's not how the human body works. Why don't we celebrate the process of life and giving birth, rather than pointing "There's a belly. Tee-hee, tee-hee." No shit it's a belly. People are dumb, but they're not that dumb.

*By the way, I love that image. On so many levels.

Fashion Magazines: The agony! The irony!

Yes, yes, I know. I've said it once, and I've said it again: fashion magazines do NOT cause anorexia.

So. Got that one out of the way.

I will, however, have you know that "out of the way" is NOT the same as "off the hook." They provide an unrealistic ideal, the provide plenty of triggers to start an eating disorder, as well as a guise under which it may flourish. Not only that, but they make dieting and anorexia and bulimia seem almost normal. Doesn't every girl diet? And want flat abs?

Courtney Martin addresses this in her new book Perfect Girls, Starving Daughters. And while she doesn't specifically take on magazines, she does take on the popular culture.

There's the debate of life imitating art or art imitating life. Frankly, it's a bit of both. The whole psychology of it (or at least my take on it) is rather long and involved for right now, so I'll save it. Every time a stick-thin model is featured on a cover, or a story about a model with an eating disorder is published, the publishing magnates are always quick to crow, "But look at the research! Anorexia is, like, totally genetic!"

True. Don't point so hard, there, honey- you might break a nail.

But because people with EDs don't pop out of the womb not eating and scared of food, there's got to be something in the environment as well.

And the really really messed up part is that I didn't realize how messed up everyone was about food until I dared to recover from anorexia.

I see it all over, every day, in almost every person I meet. The vet told me my cat had been gaining too much weight. I wanted to say, "Put her on a diet? I'll put her on a frigging diet! Don't tell me about diets!" This woman was very nice. She really was, and did seem concerned about my cat's health. Don't get me wrong. But my cat has very cute 'tocks and I'm not going to starve the poor thing because she's not on the proper weight chart.*

Which brings me to my point. You know those Google newsfeeds on the side of my blog I've referred to before? I found this gem in amongst them today: Fashion Magazines Don't Encourage Anorexia. Seeing that it was by the gossip magazine, Jossip, I braced myself.

I didn't brace myself enough. Because this, my friends, was the subhead:

If they did, why would they use chunkers like Jessica Biel?

Merciful God in heaven.

I'm not completely up to date on my celebrity gossip, but I looked at the picture of the Elle Magazine cover to which they were referring.



So...let me get this straight. The above image is "chunky"? What does that make me? The freaking Himalayas?

I don't think so. Curvy, yes. Chunky? Nope.

And, for the record, Jessica Biel isn't either.

Maybe the gossip columnist meant it tongue-in-cheek. If it did, it was quite distasteful. Disgusting, really. The headline of the article, though says it all: that magazines don't encourage anorexia. Ah, but they do. Sometimes under the outright blatant images that Thou shalt look like her or under the subtler aspects of "this is perfection" and "this is healthy." They then give you ideas for how to get healthy (check out any teen or woman's magazine/website. If there's not a diet on there, I'll pay you.) And so the cycle begins. Magazines don't cause anorexia, but they DO encourage it. They encourage the environment and the triggers, and all that goes along with it.


*If they develop those for cats, I'll scream. And then leave tuna scraps at the door.

Older Posts Home

ED Bites on Facebook!

ED Bites is on Twitter!

Search ED Bites

People's HealthBlogger Awards 2009
People's HealthBlogger Awards 2009 - Best 100 Winner!
Wellsphere

About Me

My photo
I'm a science writer, a jewelry design artist, a bookworm, a complete geek, and mom to a wonderful kitty. I am also recovering from a decade-plus battle with anorexia nervosa. I believe that complete recovery is possible, and that the first step along that path is full nutrition.

Drop me a line!

Have any questions or comments about this blog? Feel free to email me at carrie@edbites.com



nour·ish: (v); to sustain with food or nutriment; supply with what is necessary for life, health, and growth; to cherish, foster, keep alive; to strengthen, build up, or promote



Archives

Popular Posts

Followers


Recent Comments