Say "what"?

I was reading Dr. Deb's blog the other day when I stumbled across a post in which she asked her readers to examine "what", not "why".

As a writer, scientist, and generally curious (okay, sometimes nosy) person, I think humans have almost an innate tendency to ask why. It's often the first question that little kids ask: why? Why does she get a bigger cookie than me? Why can't I drive the car? Why is it light during the day and dark at night?

Part of our evolutionary success as a species is due to our curiosity and ability to learn, so it's no wonder that, when something happens, we ask why.

Don't get me wrong- why is a mighty fine question to ask. I do it often, frequently in the form of "Why am I always on the commuter train that's broken?"* But it might not always be the most helpful. Especially when you're in the throes of an eating disorder.

I asked myself why I got sick all the time. I wanted to know. I was convinced that the second I knew the answer, I would be cured. Fixed. All gone. Because then I would know why I was starving myself and then I would magically stop and things would get better.

Then I met a therapist who started asking me "what" questions. I would show up in her office every week and she would ask: what happened this week? What is going on right now? What can you do to get through this? What can you do to make it better? What can you say to the eating disorder when it starts bugging you?

It was simple. It was concrete. It wasn't a sturm und drang process of torturing myself with a sort-of schizophrenic Socratic method. I could inch my way forward- even if I didn't know why I was leaving my current destination behind.

As I got to a better place, I could start to ask why. Why am I always so anxious? Why are my moods unpredictable and sad? Why does not eating feel better?

Says Dr. Deb:

But there are times, especially during a crisis, when "Why" is not the best question to ask oneself.

In my work, I always feel that "What" helps to move you out of a difficult moment.

What has a directionality. Why keeps one stuck in circular thinking.

What offers solutions. Why offers no game plan.

So, the next time you find yourself in a bad place, experiencing a difficult moment or overwhelmed with so much, ask yourself, "What can I do to make things better? not "Why is this happening to me?

Once the crisis is over you can search for the psychological or behavioral "Why".

*The answer? They're ALL broken.
**And no, this doesn't make me feel any better.

posted under , |


Harriet said...

So true, Carrie! I tend to obsessively perseverate about things, and the big why is a big part of that. Recently I took some mindfulness training, which is all about the what and the right here, right now. It helps.

mary said...

That sounds simple, just change the question and lead yourself right on out. Somehow when we are in the midst of wallowing we forget, again.

Mindfulness training sounds like a good idea Harriet. Will you do some for me?

So, "what to do today" is the question I'll ponder.
Have a good one./*******

Cammy said...

As a scientist and I make my living on asking "why," and therapy has definitely made me realize the value of stopping to ask "what" when it comes to my life. The first things my T asks every week is "WHAT have you done for yourself?" and "WHAT have you been thinking about?" I guess for me asking why has been an obstacle because I feel like I have no excuses (no sexual abuse, no overbearing mother, was never made fun of as a kid, no this, no that, etc) that frequently contribute to an ED, it makes me feel sort of like the problem is invalid without an obvious answer to why.
You make an excellent point in this post, as always!

A:) said...

What is definately better than why.
I didn't spend much time in treatment or in therapy wondering WHY I got my ED (and let's face it -- when you have had it for a while, the whole original why might be outdated) -- but what is important -- how is also important.

As in,
HOW will you get through this day/week.
WHAT can you implement to help you.
HOW will you accomplish what you are planning to do.

Ask why later:P


Carrie said...

I like that idea of adding the "how". It makes a lot of sense. "What" seems to be setting the goal, "how" is getting there.

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home

ED Bites on Facebook!

ED Bites is on Twitter!

Search ED Bites

About Me

My photo
I'm a science writer, a jewelry design artist, a bookworm, a complete geek, and mom to a wonderful kitty. I am also recovering from a decade-plus battle with anorexia nervosa. I believe that complete recovery is possible, and that the first step along that path is full nutrition.

Drop me a line!

Have any questions or comments about this blog? Feel free to email me at

nour·ish: (v); to sustain with food or nutriment; supply with what is necessary for life, health, and growth; to cherish, foster, keep alive; to strengthen, build up, or promote


Popular Posts


Recent Comments